Stop Focusing on Test Scores

Civil Beat shared an article recently: Data Shows a Dramatic Difference in Test Scores Between Hawaii Schools.  

Stop already! These headlines and articles about declining test scores, both locally and nationally, are not helping schools; in fact, they may be adding to the challenges and stressors our public schools are already facing with declining enrollment, disengaged students, exhausted teachers, and political discord. The problem is not the students or the teachers. The truth is that the old model of K-12 schools is no longer applicable or relevant for today’s students. In our rapidly-changing 21st century world, it is more important than ever for schools to prepare students for their futures instead of preparing students for high-stakes testing. 

Of course our kids need to learn to read, write, and learn history, science, and the arts. Of course they need to have math knowledge. But the way they learn essential skills and knowledge does not have to be through one-size-fits all (boring) textbooks and workbooks, with end-of-unit tests that often measure short-term recall rather than long-term application. It doesn’t mean students need to be in classrooms with grade level peers following grade level standards. Our classrooms should be exciting places of learning with students working in diverse groups to grapple with problems that impact us now and in the future. In the process, students read and research, discuss, listen, summarize, learn by doing, and make sense of what they learned. They ask questions which often leads to more questions and even deeper learning. Students come up with possible solutions and agree on how they will share what they learned with an authentic audience. When students work with others, they learn the value of teamwork and listening to other points of view. They learn to recognize and embrace their own strengths, interests, and challenges as well as those of their peers. The teacher is an active learner in that classroom as well, guiding students in their learning, asking probing questions, and providing specialized instruction and feedback when necessary. 

Realizing that the old model of school was not meeting the needs of today’s learners, schools across the nation and in our world have transitioned to make education more relevant for their students. Project-based or problem-based learning, language-immersion schools, international schools, learning academies, and work apprenticeships are a few examples of how education is evolving. In those settings, students are engaged, learning about and working on problems that impact them now and in the future: food sustainability, trash, homelessness, immigration challenges, climate change, transportation, cultural issues . . . the list is endless. With teacher guidance, students are delving deeper into the kinds of problems that adults and government leaders are grappling with. It is real-world, important work. There may not be a common test for students at the end, but there is accountability; students document their learning journey through reflective journals, videos, tools like Unrulr, or individual conferences with their teachers. Check out the What School Could Be on-line community; the movement to reimagine education is thriving throughout the world. And when students are engaged in these real-world projects, they truly become empathetic problem-seekers and problem-solvers. 

Imagine a world where students learn to work with others and to advocate for their ideas with their team members from the time they enter kindergarten and throughout their educational experience. They become better listeners, are able to communicate their thoughts and feelings, and learn to compromise. As students work with those who may come from different backgrounds or who have different experiences, they will hopefully develop empathy, the ability to see things from another person’s perspectives and to feel their emotions. I firmly believe that empathy is lacking in many adults today, and that is what has led to a deep divide in our communities and across the nation. 

And it starts with school. As long as we continue to focus on test scores and dividing students based on their academic ability, we will have failed a significant number of those who may not fit the model of a “good student” but who have important skills and ideas that will be valued in their adult life. We can and must do better. 

So let’s stop focusing on test scores and reimagine school instead. 

I Shed a Few Tears Last Night

 I had never cried over any election results before, even when my husband lost two elections in his political career. But I shed a few tears last night. 

The results of the election hit me hard. I was cautiously optimistic, certain that our citizens would elect the most qualified person who had viable plans for our country’s future. My heart was heavy as the results were revealed, and I hurt. I hurt for the suffragettes who came before us who fought for the right for women to vote. I hurt for those who hoped that maybe one day, their daughter or granddaughter might break the glass ceiling and become the first woman President. I hurt for women legislators who had to fight to provide equal opportunities for females through legislation such as Title IX. I hurt for parents and educators who encouraged young ladies to be their best, to study hard, and to not be afraid to enter fields that were previously male-dominated. The election of the first woman President in our country would validate for young girls that they, too, could aspire to the highest office in our country. 

It was not to be . .  . again. 

Earlier this summer, I reshared a blog I had written back in 2016 (“Why is It Taking So Long?). I also wrote a short blog (“Our Children are Watching”) because I was so concerned about all the name-calling and misinformation on mainstream and social media. I read tweets from both sides of the aisle; I watched the short snippets that were posted of the candidates speaking at rallies, on podcasts, or in interviews. I was constantly checking my phone for updates. It was exhausting, but I couldn’t or wouldn’t stop. 

I didn’t support Kamala because she is a woman; I loved her message of hope for all of us who call the United States of America our home. I loved her plans to take our country forward and to unite our nation of its divisiveness. I was (almost) convinced that America would make the right choice, and I was so, so hopeful. But I was wrong.

Today, Dan Rather shared a post on Steady, titled “Now What?” He writes, “Let yourself grieve, but don’t surrender to despair.” I am taking his words to heart. We don’t know what the future will hold for us, but as this Native American quote states: We don’t inherit this world from our ancestors. We borrow it from our children.” Let’s work together to make a difference for them. 

I don’t know how many more times I will have the opportunity to vote for our President of the United States. If I live to 100 (!), that’s 7 more chances. Maybe, just maybe, I will see our first woman President. 

Play Jazz, Not Classical (essay)

I remember my school leader training many years ago. The principal-presenter shared this message with us at the conclusion of his inspiring presentation. He said, “Play jazz, not classical.” Little did I know that those four words would guide me throughout my years as a principal.

What did play jazz mean? I believe it gave me permission to improvise, to be spontaneous, to take risks. As a school leader, I needed to build relationships, to value people for their strengths as well as their challenges, to greet each day as an opportunity to make a difference, and to continuously improve. It meant trusting our staff to be their best as they worked collaboratively to make our school work so our students could thrive. And just as jazz musicians have moments in a performance to solo, to improvise and create their own unique sounds and rhythms spontaneously, we needed to give our staff and students opportunities to shine, to share, and to be recognized for the work they do.

Classical music, on the other hand, is structured and follows a written score. Each member of the orchestra must know their part and how they fit into the whole performance; there is no deviation from the musical score. If I were to describe classical school leaders, I would say that they focus more on compliance and fidelity, on ensuring that every teacher is implementing the agreed-upon curriculum, and on enforcing guidelines for assignments and assessments. 

As I embarked on my school leader journey, I worried that there might be a disconnect between what I believed school could be and what was expected of me. I was aware that generally our school systems had changed very little since the Industrial Age, with neat rows of students and the teacher in front of the classroom. Teachers followed a curriculum based on grade level or course requirements, and students completed assignments and met expectations in order to move on to the next level. Most schools are structured like classical music. I wanted to play jazz. How could I best straddle the fine line between what school could be and what was expected of me as part of a statewide education system?

I searched for answers. I listened to other principals at meetings and training sessions. I read articles and books. I became more comfortable straddling the line between classical and jazz. A game-changer for me was when our school librarian showed me the power of on-line connections via Twitter. Reading other Tweets, joining on-line community discussions, and sharing my concerns and questions–and receiving suggestions from other school leaders–gave me confidence, knowing that I was not alone in my vision for our school. I joined a Google community for education leaders, began reading educator blogs, and I learned to walk a fine line between following required mandates while being flexible and honoring our school’s vision. Our teachers and students thrived in this joyful, collaborative environment focused on deeper learning. Students, teachers, and parents embraced project-based learning, and they were truly making a difference in their community. As a military-impacted school which served students from schools across the nation and the world, it was gratifying when parents shared how proud their children were to share their learning. “All schools should teach this way,” was a common theme in their parent surveys. 

And then I retired, and the world changed. It’s hard for me to fathom the changes that have taken place in our world. In those six short years, we experienced a worldwide pandemic, Zoom became a household word, natural disasters and climate change continued to cause havoc in our world, and artificial intelligence burst into our lives, enabling a computer or robot to perform tasks that, in the past, were reserved for humans.

Today, our world has become increasingly divisive, and schools are confronted with challenges such as the banning of books and curriculum content, an increase in school violence, and addressing gender equity issues. This has resulted in concerns about student and staff mental health and well-being. At the same time, schools are dealing with teacher burnout, teacher shortages and the lack of adequate compensation for the increased workload teachers are experiencing. Some of these issues were already brewing pre-pandemic, but they seem to have magnified in the last few years. 

I believe strongly that professional learning needs to be tailored to support teachers as they navigate these challenging times. We can introduce teachers to resources that are accessible, free, and available as professional learning tools. I read blogs and articles, listen to podcasts, and engage on social media. Perspectives from different educators have given me new insight into how schools or districts make learning meaningful for students. Additionally, as a host for “Elevating Teacher Voice” in the What School Could Be community, I have had the opportunity to invite guest bloggers to share their writing and to engage in discussions afterwards. Earlier this year, Jennifer D. Klein was a guest on our virtual event, and she shared her writing piece, Manifesto on a Life in Education: A Call to the Next Generation of Educators. Although I had already read this blog ahead of time, hearing Jennifer read it aloud was powerful and emotional. The conversation afterwards was rich, and I left the session grateful for the opportunity to be a part of the discussion with Jennifer. These “Elevating Teacher Voice” guest writers share powerful blogs and I gain new perspectives on education, whether I am actively engaged or quietly listening and reflecting. For the writers, it is an opportunity to receive feedback, to answer questions, to clarify their thinking, and to hear from others about the impact of their writing. For the listeners, it is an opportunity to reflect on what was heard, to ask questions, to add to the conversation, and to come away with new ideas. 

Back in 2018, just as I was getting ready to retire, I read Ted Dintersmith’s book, What School Could Be. His retelling of his journey across America to visit two hundred schools in all fifty states gave me hope that maybe, finally, we could reimagine education as one that engages students, encourages them to be problem-seekers and problem-solvers, and gives them the tools to be self-directed critical thinkers who can make a difference in this world. Ted visited our state last, and here’s what he wrote: “I visited one spectacular school after another all across Hawai`i. They were all types (public, private, and charter), with kids of all backgrounds, achieving impressive results in all sorts of ways.” He added, “These visits were like watching the finale of the Fourth of July fireworks celebration–one spectacular burst of innovation after another.” Reading this book made me realize that many schools across our nation are already playing jazz, not classical. We don’t often hear about those schools, but it gave me hope for the future of education for our children. 

Those of us who believe that education can be the key to creating a better world in the future will continue to do this work. Let’s invite and encourage more people to join the jazz band!

Play Jazz, Not Classical

 I was asked to write an essay for the Chronicle in tthe What School Could Be community. I struggled, and my original piece was not to my satisfaction. I wanted to write something that would resonate with educators.

I was reminded of how challenging writing can be.  I was reminded of the time I wrote my books; it took many drafts, many revisions, and lots of rewriting, based on comments from my editor. It’s true that a writer needs to have a thick skin. I needed to listen to others in order to improve what I had written. Writing this essay reminded me of how much I appreciate that process. 

My essay is available at this link. https://www.whatschoolcouldbe.org/blog/play-jazz-not-classical

I would love your feedback 😊

Our Children are Watching

 Our children are watching. 

Our children learn much more than academics when they are in school. Schools provide an opportunity for students to  grow as people, to learn how to get along with others, to show empathy for those who may be struggling, to make new friends, to be responsible for what they say and do, to persevere when things are challenging, to listen to other viewpoints, to learn to lead as well as to follow, and to find the joy in learning together with their classmates. Schools are also important venues for learning life skills such as responsibility, perseverance, communication, critical thinking, and problem-solving, skills that students carry with them throughout their lives. 

When I was a principal, our behavioral expectations were simple: Take care of yourself. Take care of others. Take care of our school.  Most schools have similar behavioral expectations. We know that academic success is emphasized in schools, but kids who care about the world they live in and who contribute positively to their community is just as important. 

Which leads me to this: Our children are watching. These are very contentious times. The race for our nation’s leadership is on very public display. What are our children seeing on social media and the news media? Are the discussions, interviews, and debates positive and respectful?  What are the candidates’ plans to make our country and the world a better place? Are the candidates debating the issues and sharing accurate data?  Do they seek to unite us as a nation or to divide us? 

As a society, I believe it is our responsibility to leave this world a better place for the next generation, and that was always my goal as an educator. I constantly remind myself of the Native American proverb: “We do not inherit this world from our ancestors. We borrow it from our children.” I hope you agree that striving for a better world for our children should be the goal of all of us, but most importantly, for the next leader of our country. 

When Will We Learn?

There was another school shooting last week. It was the 45th school shooting this year, and it happened at the start of a new school year. Two students and two teachers were killed at Apalachee High School in Georgia. According to this Washington Post article,  there have been 417 school shootings since 1999 when 15 students died at Columbine High School. I remember the shock and the outrage that such a thing could happen in one of the schools in our country. Today, a school shooting is often relegated to the back pages of the newspaper. 

Back in February 2018, I wrote a blog post after the shooting at Marjory Stoneman Douglas High School in Florida, killing 17 people and injuring another 17. In the aftermath, those high school students became activists, advocating for sensible changes to the gun laws. They were passionate and articulate and organized March for Our Lives to “demand a world free of gun violence.“ Today, that organization continues to push for sensible gun control laws: 

As a retired school principal, school shootings continue to affect me immensely. I know that all of the practice drills and professional development trainings might not adequately prepare and keep our students and staff safe during an actual school shooting. Parents send their kids to school and expect us to keep them safe. Schools take that responsibility seriously.

Back in 2012, I wrote a blog about a lockdown situation at our school. (A Safe School) The situation was under control, but we could not relax until we got the all-clear from the military. I remember overhearing a parent come in the next day to request a form to homeschool her children. I went over to chat with her about her decision. She shared that when she heard about the lockdown, she experienced a high level of anxiety and stress. It was nothing against the school; she just needed to know that her children were safe. 

Many schools and school districts already face budget deficits. This article by Pew Research shares how schools have adapted to this new normal: “U.S. school security procedures have become more widespread in recent years but are still unevenly adopted.” When funds need to be allocated to changing door locks or installing video cameras or hiring armed security guards, that could mean eliminating staff or having to choose between upgrading technology for student use or providing mental health services for students who are struggling. 

There is no easy solution. But if we can agree that schools should be safe places for our students and staff, perhaps the discussion will be more productive and will lead to sensible solutions. I hope our country can agree on that. 

So Many Memories

 Our Mom passed away peacefully at her home on May 14, 2024. She was 96 years old at the time, and my siblings and I have been navigating the cleaning up of her home while we ponder our next steps. We knew this day would come eventually, and it’s not been easy.

Mom was a private person. As I shared in this blog from October 2015, Mom was special; she helped to shape my siblings and me into the people we are today. When Mom and Dad became grandparents, their home became the place-to-be on special holidays, for celebrations,  or for “corn parties” when Dad’s crop was ready to be harvested. These get-togethers were filled with stories and laughter and catching-up. We saw the grandchildren - our kids - grow up together as lifelong friends as well as cousins. Then these kids grew up and had kids of their own. Our family home that Mom and Dad bought back in 1969 was filled with even more laughter. 

Dad passed away in 2013 (Aloha, Dad). Since then, Mom lived alone in that 5-bedroom home. As she grew older, my siblings and I took turns spending time with her; we needed to watch her more carefully as she became less independent. And now, as we go through her drawers and closets, we’re getting an even greater insight about what made our Mom tick.

Mom loved her family, and as I cleaned out her desk drawers, I came across so many greeting cards and thank-you cards.  I hope Mom occasionally took them out to re-read because they were filled with sweet thoughts of appreciation and love. Mom and Dad also read the newspaper from front to back every day, I was surprised that she had cut out and saved articles written about or by her children and grandchildren and kept them in binders or file folders. As my siblings and I go over to clean and purge, we sometimes get caught up, looking through Mom’s photo albums or going through her scrapbooks. 

I know that especially in the later years, it was difficult to think of what to get Mom for her birthday, Mothers’ Day, or Christmas. As we clean, we are finding unused gift cards, brand-new items that were unwrapped but never used, clothes with the price tags still intact, and other well-meaning gifts that Mom never had the opportunity to use or enjoy. We are donating many of these items to charity, and we hope they will be enjoyed by those who receive them. 

We are encouraging our children (Mom’s grandchildren) to go through Mom’s items and to take things that they want or that remind them of her.  Three items I took from Mom’s home are a bracelet that the ladies at Wahiawa General Hospital made for newborns; our last name is misspelled, but I love that Mom kept all five of our bracelets. I also took my baby book; Mom had taped a penny from the year I was born on the first page and recorded my milestones including my first photograph. And I took my Dad’s bento-pail, his lunchbox, the one he took to work in the pineapple fields when they first got married. It was tucked way in the back of the kitchen cabinet What a find!

Mom and Dad bought their home when I was a senior in high school so I didn’t spend too many years there before getting married and starting our own family in our own home. Now that Mom and Dad have both passed, I know another family will move in and make their own memories in that special place. It would be impossible for me to share everything about what Mom and Dad’s home has meant to our extended family, and time has a way of moving on whether we like it or not. But I am grateful for all of the wonderful memories of Mom and Dad’s home, and I am hopeful that the next family will feel the love that we all shared in that special place. 

The bracelet that the volunteers made for newborns at Wahiawa General Hospital. The name is misspelled - it should be AMEMIYA - but it is nevertheless, a very special keepsake.

I knew Mom had a book for each of us, so when I became a Mom, I kept one for each of our sons. 

Dad’s bento (lunch) pail that he took to work when he worked as a laborer in the pineapple fields. 

It is still in great condition!